Meta fined $887M for accessing Android users’ photos

Italy slaps Meta with a massive $887M penalty after Facebook accessed Android photo galleries using a generic authorization

Italian regulators hit Meta with an $887 million fine over a Facebook feature that scanned roughly 20 million Android users' photo galleries without specific consent. ©Image Credit: Unsplash / Julio Lopez
Italian regulators hit Meta with an $887 million fine over a Facebook feature that scanned roughly 20 million Android users' photo galleries without specific consent. ©Image Credit: Unsplash / Julio Lopez

When you open up a social media app on your phone, you probably assume your personal photo gallery remains safely tucked away unless you deliberately choose to share something. Regulators and Android users were in for a shock when they found that was not the case. Tech giant Meta has just run into a massive regulatory roadblock in Europe over how it handles private phone memories and accesses private photos on Android phones without the explicit permission of their owners.

A costly privacy penalty in Italy

Italy’s data protection authority has handed Facebook parent company Meta a staggering $887 million fine for accessing users’ photos without their specific consent. According to investigators, Meta accessed users’ photos, videos and metadata belonging to Italian users through the Facebook application for Android devices.

How a photo-suggestion feature sparked a huge fine

The penalty stems from an investigation into the Facebook feature on Android devices, which has been available since 2023, that suggested photos and videos directly from users’ personal phone galleries as post ideas while they were browsing.

According to regulators, the app accessed photographs, videos and related metadata belonging to an estimated 20 million Android users in Italy without obtaining specific consent or even properly informing them. Italian authorities noted that Facebook requested gallery access through a single authorization valid for the entire app, preceded by a generic notice for enabling other features that did not clarify users were also authorizing gallery suggestions.

Meta’s lack of cooperation during investigation raised fine

Italian authorities cited Meta’s lack of cooperation during the investigation as part of the reasons the tech giant was handed the huge fine, which amounts to 0.4% of Meta’s annual turnover and ranks among the largest penalties an Italian authority has ever imposed on a tech company.

Meta plans to fight the decision

As you would expect, Meta strongly disagrees with the regulatory ruling and plans to appeal the decision.

“We strongly disagree with the [regulator’s] assessment of the facts, its application of the law and the disproportionate level of the fine,” Meta told the BBC. “This is a straightforward feature which helps people post photos and videos to Facebook. People must give permission on their device before it can operate and they can change this permission at any time via their settings.”

What follows

Italian regulators have given Meta 60 days to disable the feature by default and require separate, explicit consent moving forward. Regulators also require Meta to clearly signpost what the consent request is for, letting users know it involves photo gallery access and explaining how they can disable it.

While the financial penalty amounts to a small fraction of the company’s massive global turnover, it is still a big hit for the tech giant. This privacy showdown proves that handling user media requires crystal-clear communication every single step of the way. And while we are here, you might want to rethink those permissions you granted to those apps because they might be getting more than you intend to share.

Source: The Guardian, BBC